Missouri Lawsuit for personal injuries against Prime Tanning Corp Lawsuit
Thursday, July 30th, 2009Introduction: Environmental activist Erin Brockovich, of the award-winning Julia Roberts’ movie fame, comes to the aid of a group of northwest Missouri citizens. Learn about the class-action lawsuit filed against the Prime Tanning Corp of St. Joseph that’s making national headlines.
Question 1: What exactly is this lawsuit about and who’s involved?
Several personal injury lawsuits have been filed against Prime Tanning Corp. of St. Joseph re: the distribution of toxic sludge as fertilizer. The most significant being a class-action lawsuit on behalf of all residents in Andrew, Buchanan, Clinton and DeKalb counties. Kansas City-based National beef Packing Co. acquired Prime Tanning in April, and renamed it National Beef Leathers, is also named in the suit.
The suit claims that Prime Tanning gave contaminated sludge from its plant to farmers in those four northwest Missouri counties to use on their fields as fertilizer. The suit alleges that the sludge contained high levels of hexavalent cromium, a known carcinogen, and the same carcinogen that prompted a $333 million settlement from Pacific Gas & Energy for exposing a California town to the chemical, the basis for the 2000 film “Erin Brockovich” starring Julia Roberts.
According to the lawsuit, Prime Tanning used hexavalent chromium to remove hair from hides in the tanning process and the resulting waste product was collected as sludge. Prime Tanning denies the sludge contained the chemical, but the lawsuit contends that they gave it to the farmers for decades (1983 to early 2009) to in order to avoid paying for disposing of it in a landfill.
Plaintiffs in the lawsuits are alleging that the hexavalent chromium, or chromium 6, caused an outbreak of brain tumors in the Cameron, Mo. area.
Rick Ream who oversaw the land applications of sludge is also named in the lawsuit.
Question 2: What is Erin Brockovich’s involvement?
1) Hexavalent cromium is the same carcinogen that was involved in the California case on which the movie was based on.
2) The investigator who did work for the Brockovich case lead this investigation as well. Also Attorney Thomas V. Girardi of LA, who worked on behalf of the plaintiffs in the California case, is helping with this case.
3) Brockovich, attorneys and the investigators held a meeting in Cameron April 22nd to discuss the lawsuit and results of the investigation with the community.
Question 3: What did the investigation reveal and what was the Tannery’s response?
For a year now, the Environmental Protection Agency, Missouri Department of Natural Resources, Missouri Department of Health and a state epidemiologist have been investigating what residents believe are a high number of brain tumors in the area — more than 70 since 1996. The epidemiologist has said those numbers don’t seem abnormally high.
Investigators took numerous soil samples, and the results of those showed high levels of hexavalent chromium.
Representatives for National Beef said its available records indicate that it used only trivalent chromium, a non-carcinogen, in the tanning process since acquiring the facility. National Beef Leathers has stopped giving away the sludge as fertilizer.
The original tanner owners told the state the sludge did not contain the hexavalent chromium, according to the lawsuit.
Question 4: What is happening now with the personal injury lawsuit?
Missouri Attorney General Chris Koster’s office said that tests will be done on land in Northwest Missouri where a farmer had spread the sludge before the company said it would stop giving it away.
The latest turn of events is that a Motion for Temporary Restraining order was issued days after the lawsuit was filed by the plaintiffs after they discovered that National Beef Leathers was planning to destroy 80 pallets of old documents they identified as no longer needed following the purchase of Prime Tanning.
Clinton County Judge Brent Elliot, ordered that all past and present papers related to the sludge be preserved, and a hearing on the injunction is scheduled for July 14.
Also, a prior lawsuit filed involving the brain tumors alleged that the Rockwool Insulation facility near Cameron was responsible for the brain tumors by releasing chemicals and contaminants. The Environmental Protection Agency and Missouri Department of Natural Resources plan to examine the soil at the Rockwool Insulation as well.